Science
*Reviews (4 journal pages, on
average) describe new
developments o f interdisciplinary significance and highlight
unresolved questions and future directions. All Reviews undergo
peer review. They include an abstract, an introduction that outlines
the main point, and brief subheadings. A maximum of 40 references is
suggested. Most Reviews are solicited by the editors, but unsolicited
submissions may also be considered
Research Articles (up to ~4500
words, Including references, notes and captions, or ~5 journal pages)
are expected to present a
major advance. Research Articles include an abstract, an
introduction, up to six figures or tables, sections with brief
subheadings, and a maximum of 40 references. Materials and Methods
should usually be included in supporting online material, which should
also include information needed to support the paper's conclusions.
Reports (up to ~2500 words or
~3 journal pages) present important new research results of broad
significance. Reports should include an abstract, an
introductory paragraph, up to four figures or tables, and a maximum of
30 references. Materials and Methods should usually be included in
supporting online material, which should also include information
needed to support the paper's conclusions.
Nature
Publication Criteria
* report original scientific research (the main results
and conclusions must not have been published or submitted elsewhere)
* are of outstanding scientific importance
* reach a conclusion of interest to an
interdisciplinary readership.
Further editorial criteria may be applicable for different kinds of
papers, as follows:
* large dataset papers: should aim to either report a fully
comprehensive dataset, defined by complete and extensive validation, or
provide significant technical advance or scientific insight.
* technical papers: papers that make solely
technical advances will be considered in cases where the technique
reported will have significant impacts on communities of fellow
researchers.
Articles are original reports whose conclusions
represent a substantial advance in understanding of an important
problem and have immediate, far-reaching implications. They do
not normally exceed 5 pages of Nature and have no more than 50
references. (One page of undiluted text is about 1,300 words.)
Articles have a summary, separate from the main text, of up to 150
words, which does not have references, and does not contain numbers,
abbreviations, acronyms or measurements unless essential. It is aimed
at readers outside the discipline. This summary contains a paragraph
(2-3 sentences) of basic-level introduction to the field; a brief
account of the background and rationale of the work; a statement of the
main conclusions (introduced by the phrase 'Here we show' or its
equivalent); and finally, 2-3 sentences putting the main findings into
general context so it is clear how the results described in the paper
have moved the field forwards.
Articles are typically 3,000 words of text, beginning with up to 500
words of referenced text expanding on the background to the work (some
overlap with the summary is acceptable), before proceeding to a
concise, focused account of the findings, ending with one or two short
paragraphs of discussion.
Articles typically have 5 or 6 display items (figures or tables).
Letters are short reports of original research
focused on an outstanding finding whose importance means that it
will be of interest to scientists in other fields.
They do not normally exceed 4 pages of Nature, and have no more than 30
references. They begin with a fully referenced paragraph, ideally of
about 200 words, but certainly no more than 300 words, aimed at readers
in other disciplines. This paragraph starts with a 2-3 sentence basic
introduction to the field; followed by a one-sentence statement of the
main conclusions starting 'Here we show' or equivalent phrase; and
finally, 2-3 sentences putting the main findings into general context
so it is clear how the results described in the paper have moved the
field forwards.
Insight, *Review and Progress articles
Nature publishes two kinds of review, Review and Progress articles. It
also publishes commissioned collections of review and other related
material on one scientific theme as 'Insights' several times a
year. For further information about Insights, contact the
Insights Editor. Reviews and
Progress articles inform a broad readership about fields in which there
have been recent, important advances. Progress articles differ
from Reviews in that they focus on current papers of outstanding
interest that are setting new standards in a field. Because of their
topicality. Progress articles should be written and submitted within a
few weeks of Nature's editors expressing interest in a synopsis.
* They focus on one topical aspect of a field rather
than providing a comprehensive literature survey.
* They can be controversial, but in this case should
briefly indicate opposing viewpoints. They should not be focused on the
author's own work. Language should be simple, novel concepts defined
and specialist terminology explained.
* They are peer-reviewed, and are substantially
edited by Nature's editors in consultation with the author.
Review Articles survey recent
developments in a topical area of scientific research or, on occasion,
can be more wide-ranging. They do not generally occupy
more than 6 pages of Nature.
* Progress articles are shorter reviews of topical,
fast-moving fields, and do not exceed 4 pages of Nature.
* Reviews should not generally be more than 6 pages long. There should
be no more than 100 references and ideally half that number. Display
items and explanatory boxes (used for explanation of technical points
or background material) are welcomed.
Most articles are commissioned, but authors wishing to submit an
unsolicited Review or Progress must do so through our online submission
system.
* The synopsis should outline the basic structure of
the article; list the material to be covered with an indication of the
proposed depth of coverage; and indicate how the material will be
logically arranged.
* The synopsis should be accompanied by a 300-500
word outline of the background to the topic which summarizes the
progress made to date and should also make the case succinctly for
publication in a topical, interdisciplinary journal.
* Synopses prepared at this level of detail enable
Nature's editors to provide editorial input before they commission the
article, and can reduce the need for substantial editorial revisions at
a later stage.
* The synopsis should include any very recent, key
publications in the area (no more than five), and state the last time
the topic was reviewed (if it has been reviewed previously).
Nature Geosciences
Letter
A Letter reports an
important novel research study. Letters typically occupy four
printed journal pages. The text is limited to 2,000 words, including
the introductory paragraph, but excluding Methods, references and
figure legends. Letters should have no more than 3—5 display items
(figures and/or tables). References are limited to 30. This format
begins with a title of, at most, 90 characters (including spaces),
followed by an introductory paragraph (not abstract) of approximately
200 words, summarizing the background, rationale, main results
(introduced by "Here we show" or some equivalent phrase) and
implications of the study. This paragraph should be fully referenced
and should be considered part of the main text, so that any subsequent
introductory material avoids too much redundancy with the introductory
paragraph.
Article
An Article is a substantial
novel research study of high quality and general interest to the
geoscience community. The main text (excluding introductory
paragraph, Methods, references and figure legends) is 2,000—3,000
words. Articles have 4—6 display items (figures and/or tables).
References are limited to 50. The maximum title length is 90 characters
(including spaces). The introductory paragraph is typically 150 words
and is unreferenced; it contains a brief account of the background and
rationale of the work, followed by a statement of the main conclusions
introduced by the phrase "Here we show" or some equivalent. An
introduction (without heading) of up to 500 words of referenced text
expands on the background of the work (some overlap with the summary is
acceptable), followed by a concise, focused account of the findings,
ending with one or two short paragraphs of discussion.
*Review
A Review is an
authoritative, balanced survey of recent developments in a research
field. Although reviews should be recognized as scholarly by
specialists in the field, they should be written with a view to
informing nonspecialist readers. Thus, reviews should be presented
using simple prose, avoiding excessive jargon and technical detail.
Reviews are approximately 3,000—4,000 words and typically include 4—6
display items (figures, tables or boxes). References are limited to
100; citations should be selective. Footnotes are not used. The scope
of a Review should be broad enough that it is not dominated by the work
of a single research institution, and particularly not by the authors'
own work.